Monday, February 8, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: The Passenger (1975) - Creating an Interesting "The Girl"

[Quick Summary: A journalist takes over the identity of a dead hotel neighbor, who turns out to be an hunted arms dealer.]

Why is "The Girl" here not a throw away stereotype, though her main purpose is essentially to look after and assist Locke?

I think it's because she engages him like a good tennis partner, batting the dialogue back over the net.  She also requires him to be in the present, not the past or future.

The scene below is their first meeting. Notice how quickly he tells her the truth.

46. A long room - Palacio Guell. Interior. Day.

...LOCKE: Excuse me, I'm trying to remember something.
GIRL (very naturally): Is it important?
LOCKE: No.

The Girl reacts to Locke with an absolute directness, and with an unusual absence of embarrassment.

LOCKE: Do you know what it is? I came in by accident.
GIRL: The man who built it was hit by a tram.
LOCKE: Who was he?
GIRL: Gaudi. He built this house for a corduroy manufacturer.

She gets up.

GIRL: Come.

They enter a big salon.

GIRL: They used this room for concerts. Wagner.
LOCKE: Do you think he was crazy?
GIRL: What do you think?
LOCKE: No, he wasn't.

She looks at him and laughs easily.

GIRL: How could you come in here by accident?
LOCKE: I was escaping.
GIRL (deadpan): Wow...(then seriously) From what?
LOCKE: I thought there was someone following me, somebody who might recognize me.
GIRL: Why?
LOCKE: I don't know.
GIRL: Well, I can't recognize you. Who are you?
LOCKE: I used to be someone else. But I traded him in. What about you?
GIRL (she smiles ironically): I'm in Barcelona. I'm talking to a man.

Locke smiles at her.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I was impressed that "The Girl" was a meaty part. Her only purpose is to help Locke, but that is what SHE wants, not because it's a plot crutch.

The Passenger (1975)
by Marc Peploe, Petter Wollen, and Michelangelo Antonioni

Monday, February 1, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: Excalibur (1981) - Where are the Choices With Real Consequences?

[Quick Summary: King Arthur rises to power, but his reign is plagued with .]

This is a case of a decently written script with unfortunate story issues.

First, Arthur starts off strong, but then is overtaken by more interesting characters.

Second, Arthur does not make consistent choices that have real consequences.  Yes, he does make choices, but they seem to be driven by circumstances vs. himself.*

I picked this scene below for its character choices and real consequences.  

Note how this argument feels very human, despite that they're bargaining about magical powers.  Will  Merlin uphold his principles or fall victim to his own desire?

EXT. BATTLEMENTS, CAMELOT - DUSK

....Morgana, who has been watching from the shadows, slinks up to Merlin's side.

MORGANA: Crazy old fool. You think yourself a kingmaker. Ha! a meddler, more likely. Look what a mess you've made of things.

Merlin smiles knowingly at her.

MERLIN: I? Perhaps, perhaps. I'm losing interest, Morgana...I have helped men -- or meddled in their affairs, if you would have it that way --since the dawn of time. Now let them live by their own laws. Let them stand on their own feet. The gods of once are gone forever, it is a time for men...Morgana, make a man out of me. Kiss me.

He reaches to touch her lips. She cradles his hand in hers and doesn't allow Merlin to kiss her. SH kisses his knuckles and stares into his eyes, stoking his desire.

MORGANA: You know what I want. I want the secret of true magic, how to thicken the stuff of dreams and wishes with the flesh of the world.

MERLIN: That I cannot.

She breaks away, provocative, alluring.

MORGANA: Then I will not.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I feel when characters make choices without real consequences, it comes off as false. 

ex. Guinevere runs off with Lancelot...and isn't worried about Arthur?!

Excalibur (1981)(9/28/79 draft)
by Rospo Pallenberg and John Boorman
Adapted from "Le Morte Darthur," by Rospo Pallenberg

* As Roger Ebert puts it much better: "There is another problem, too: one common not only to many movie versions of Arthurian legends, but epidemic in the modern sword-and-sorcery genre. The people in this film seem doomed to their behavior. They have no choice. Arthur is courageous as a youth, but then presides over the disintegration of the Round Table, for no apparent reason. The brave and pure Lancelot, accused of being Guenevere's lover, engages in a deadly joust to defend her honor. Not much later, however, they make love. Merlin is a great and powerful magician, but allows Morgana to outwit him; he seems to decide from moment to moment whether to possess vast powers or none. 


Since there is no consistency in the behavior of the characters, “Excalibur” is maddeningly arbitrary. Anyone is likely to do anything, and when they do, Boorman springs another battle scene on us, with horses whinnying and swords thumping into flesh until the novelty wears thin...."

Monday, January 25, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: Batman (1989) - Tension While Batman & Joker Fall in the Air

[Quick Summary: Bruce Wayne (Batman) defends Gotham against a brand new criminal, Jack Napier (Joker).]

Dark and extreme superhero movies are common today.

But in 1989, Tim Burton was breaking new ground with the colors and visuals.

This isn't the most emotionally compelling script that I've read, but I give it some slack as there were a lot of bumps on the way (writers' strike, studio fears, etc.)

However, I liked the following scene for keeping tensions high while in mid-air:

EXT. CATHEDRAL TOWER - NIGHT

Two bodies fall in pad de deux. Joker SCREAMS. SOUND OF WIND RUSHING BY.

EXT. FALLING POV - NIGHT

CAMERA FALLS DOWNWARD. Lights float lazily up AT us from the onrushing street below.

EXT. FALLING - NIGHT - TIGHT

BATMAN FIRES a hook and a line back up at the roof.

ON HOOK

It lands on roof and skitters along looking for a crevice to hook on.

ON JOKER

He stares back at Batman as he drifts away. JOKER'S LAUGHING ALL THE WAY DOWN.

ON HOOK

SKITTERING.

ON BATMAN

He spreads his cape, slowing down a bit.

ON GARGOYLE

Hook skitters to it and seizes on its grimacing jaws.

ON JOKER (SLOW MOTION)

He plummets to earth CRASHING ON CATHEDRAL STEPS. LAUGHTER STOPS!

ON BATMAN (SLOW MOTION)

HE FALLS, TURNS UPSIDE-DOWN AND STOPS in mid-air. Coming to the end of a long tether from the top of the tower. He bounces a bit and hangs upside-down. Like a bat. A SCREAM fills the air.

EXT. CHURCH STEPS - OVERHEAD ANGLE

We're looking DOWN AT the Joker, whose body lies splayed and broken o n the steps. We DRIFT DOWNWARD, CLOSER, until his FACE FILLS THE SCREEN, his chilling grin still intact.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I liked that the writers didn't try to tug at our sympathies by making the Joker have regrets at the end.  This kept up the tension in the fall.

Batman (1989)(5th draft w/revisions)
by Sam Hamm and Warren Skaaren
Based on the character created by Bob Kane

Monday, January 18, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: JFK (1991) - The Emotional Ride of Obsession

[Quick Summary: The hunt for a murderer after President John F. Kennedy is shot in Dallas, TX on Nov. 22, 1963.]

THREE THINGS I LEARNED FROM ROGER EBERT'S REVIEW:

1) FACT vs. FICTION IN FILMS.

This is not a film about the facts of the assassination, but about the feelings. “JFK” accurately reflects our national state of mind since Nov. 22, 1963. ...I believe films are the wrong medium for fact. Fact belongs in print. Films are about emotions.*

2) SO WHAT IS OLIVER STONE'S FILM ABOUT?

His film is not about the case assembled by his hero, New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison (Kevin Costner). It is about Garrison's obsession. The film's thrust is not toward truth, but toward frustration and anger.

3) WHY IS THE SCRIPT WORTH READING? It is not a pretty to look at (156 pgs. long, single spaced), however it is unusually nimble for the amount of detail.

Oliver Stone was born to make this movie. He is a filmmaker of feverish energy and limitless technical skills, able to assemble a bewildering array of facts and fancies and compose them into a film without getting bogged down. His secret is that he doesn't intend us to remember all his pieces and fit them together and arrive at logical conclusions.

I liked that the script kept focus on the emotional ride of obsession by showing what it costs.  It's the small things that are so devastating.

INT. GARRISON HOME - NIGHT (1967)

After dinner, toys scattered around the living room. Phone ringing as VIRGINIA, 6, answers it, playing with her doll. In background SCOOTER is chasing ELIZABETH around.

VIRGINIA: Hello.

MALE VOICE: Hello is this Jim Garrison's daughter?

VIRGINIA: Yes?

MALE VOICE: Virginia or Elizabeth?

VIRGINIA: Virginia.

MALE VOICE: Virginia, you're a lucky girl. Your daddy has entered you in a beauty contest. Would you like to be in a beauty contest?

VIRGINIA: That sounds fun.

MALE VOICE: I need some information from you then. How old are you?

VIRGINIA: Six.

MALE VOICE: And how tall are you?

In the STUDY, JIM watches the NEWS in horror. [News reports the death of Martin Luther King, Jr.]

MALE VOICE: And you get off from school at 3 every day?

VIRGINIA: Yes.

MALE VOICE: Do you walk home?

VIRGINIA: Uh huh.

LIZ comes to the phone, a look on her face.

LIZ (taking the phone): Who you talking to?

MALE VOICE: Okay Virginia, that's all I need to know. I'll call you again when it's time for the beauty contest.

LIZ: Who's this?...Hello?...Hello?

Pause. The man at the other end listening to Liz...He hangs up. Liz turns to Virginia.

VIRGINIA (excited): Mama I'm going to be in a beauty contest! Daddy.

LIZ: What did he ask you!

VIRGINIA:Well, he asked me everything. He asked me...          

Liz freaking.           

                                                                                INTERCUT TO:

LIZ marches into Jim's study.

LIZ: Did you enter Virginia into a beauty contest?

JIM (absorbed in the TV): What?

LIZ (hysterical): A man just called. He asked her everything! Her height, her weight, when she came home from school. 

JIM: Honey, some crackpot! Martin Luther King was just killed in Memphis!

LIZ (screaming): I don't give a damn about Martin Luther King! Your daughter's life was just threatened!

JIM: Just a crank making phone calls. Happens a dozen times a day at the office.

LIZ: Our home Jim!  A kidnapper, a murderer!

JIM (consoling): Only cowards make crank calls, egghead, nothing is going to happen (puts his arms around her).

LIZ (beats on him): How do you know? How do you know!

JIM: Get a hold of yourself.

LIZ: I'm leaving. I'm taking the kids and I'm leaving! I can't stand it anymore...

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: After reading this script, I don't remember much about it, except the emotional toll.  Which might be the point in the end.

JFK (1991)(Jan. 1991 draft)
by Oliver Stone

* "I have no doubt Cronkite was correct, from his point of view. But I am a film critic and my assignment is different than his. He wants facts. I want moods, tones, fears, imaginings, whims, speculations, nightmares. As a general principle, I believe films are the wrong medium for fact. Fact belongs in print. Films are about emotions. My notion is that “JFK” is no more, or less, factual than Stone's “Nixon” or “Gandhi,” “Lawrence of Arabia,” “Gladiator,” “Amistad,” “Out of Africa,” “My Dog Skip” or any other movie based on “real life.” All we can reasonably ask is that it be skillfully made and seem to approach some kind of emotional truth. Given that standard, “JFK” is a masterpiece."

Monday, January 11, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: Frankenstein (1931) - Dwarf on the Roof, Frankenstein Below

[Quick Summary: Dr. Frankenstein creates a Monster that runs amok.]

Screenwriting still baffles me. It's unlike any other kind of writing.

I have learned a few things though:

1) The closest analogy is still that it's a recipe or a blueprint of ideas.

2) Good writing is like a shot of aged whiskey, i.e., a complete, exciting idea in one gulp.  Harder than it sounds to stuff action, geography, emotion into a sentence.

I like how the writers show geography and height in the example below.  

Can you see the Dwarf looking through the roof and Frankenstein looking up? 

Also, note that the action (Dwarf climbing down) shows us the roof is high without telling us.

INT. LABORATORY - REVERSE SHOT

The head and shoulders of Frank-
enstein in fore, this time, shooting
up to the large opening in the roof
to where the Dwarf kneels, peering
down in. From somewhere beneath the
opening two shining steel rods, placed
about four feet apart, rise into the
air from a momentarily unseen fixture
on floor of laboratory, connecting
with the two high frequency wires,
that drop down from above.

                                             FRANKENSTEIN (sharply)
                                                      Come down, then! Help with
                                                      these attachments. We've no
                                                      time to lose.

His manner is peremptory,
indicating a high state of
nervous tension. The Dwarf,
grasping a rope, which trails
loosely from the roof, lowers
himself with quick agility to
the laboratory level. CAMERA
FOLLOWS HIS PROGRESS DOWN,
MOVING BACK to assume floor
level focus, and we get a
general view of the interior
of the laboratory.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: Sometimes it helps to set the geography for the reader first (guy above on roof) so the following action makes more sense (guy climbs down).

Frankenstein (1931)(8/12/31 draft)
by Garrett Fort and Francis Edwards Faragoh
Adaptation of Mary Shelley's novel (1818)

Monday, January 4, 2021

TODAY'S NUGGET: The Matrix (1999) - Understanding When to Add the Grand Spectacle

[Quick Summary: When a hacker learns that his life in the Matrix is a sham, he joins the resistance against the evil artificial intelligence.]

We all know that you can't build a cake on top of frosting.  You make the cake first, and the frosting is the finish.

It's the same way with the grand spectacle.  Build a solid story first, then go wild with spectacle. 

I liked this film because it did just that.  

First, the writers had something philosophical to say about fighting to believe.  

Then they added some grand spectacle on top, such as this unforgettable moment:

EXT. ROOF - DAY

...Just as she drops the final Marine, Trinity sees what's coming. Neo sees her, the fear in her face, and he knows what is behind him.

Screaming, he whirls, guns filling his hands with thought-speed.

Fingers pumping, shells ejecting, dancing up and away, we look THROUGH the sights and gun smoke AT the Agent blurred with motion --

Until the hammers click against the empty metal.

NEO: Trinity!

Agent Jones charges.

NEO: ...Help.

His GUN BOOMS as we ENTER the liquid space of --

-- BULLET -TIME.

The AIR SIZZLES with wads of lead like angry flies as Neo twists, bends, ducks just between them.

Agent Jones, still running, narrows the gap, the bullets coming faster until Neo, bent impossibly back, one hand on the ground as a spiraling gray ball shears open his shoulder.

He starts to scream as another digs a red groove across his thigh He has only time to look up, to see Agent Jones standing over him, raising his gun a final time.

AGENT JONES: Only human...

Suddenly Agent Jones stops He hears a sharp metal click.

Immediately, he whirls around and turns straight into the muzzle of Trinity's .45 --

--jammed tight to his head.

TRINITY: Dodge this!

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I like the economy of this "bullet-time" on the page. It's good frosting (but only because of the previous foundation of 'cake.')

The Matrix (1999)(shooting draft, 3/29/98)
by The Wachowski Brothers

Monday, December 28, 2020

TODAY'S NUGGET: Dirty Dozen (1967) - Setting Up the Loose Cannon

[Quick Summary: Major Reisman has to train the "Dirty Dozen," a group of felons and death row inmates, for a surprise attack on the enemy.] 

I was surprised at the detailed attention to character in this script. 

For example, Maggot, the fanatic who wants to stamp out evil women, could have easily been a cardboard stereotype.  

Instead, the writers added a beat to throw us into doubt, and set up a future event.

Notice in the scene below:
- It describes Maggot's unconscious behavior (my underlines below).
- We unsure if he is even aware what he is thinking.
- This setup is a hint that pays off when Maggot goes berserk later.

EXT. WATCHTOWER COMPOUND NIGHT

...As MAGGOT climbs down the tower and sets off around the perimeter, he keeps up a constant stream of muttered imprecations.

MAGGOT: Spitting in the face of the redeemer...That's what he's doing - defiling the purity of souls that were sent into this world to live clean...

It is doubtful whether his words even have any meaning for MAGGOT, but he breathes them out as if they were some incantation that will destroy all evil spirits.

NEW ANGLE

As he gets near REISMAN'S hut, MAGGOT's speech becomes nothing more than a fierce, rhythmic breathing, but his mouth keeps moving as if it were forming words.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I liked that the audience is ahead of the character.  We see he's unhinged, but he does not. It adds to the anticipation.

Dirty Dozen (1967)(draft dated 2/4/66)
by Nunnelly Johnson and Lukas Heller
Based on the novel by E.M. Nathanson

Monday, December 21, 2020

TODAY'S NUGGET: Wag the Dog (1997) - In Satire, Using a Betrayal to Show the Obstacle

[Quick Summary: A political player and a Hollywood producer create a fake war as a distraction to an upcoming US election.]

Satire (n.) is 

the use of irony, sarcasm, ridicule, or the like, in exposing, denouncing, deriding vice, folly, etc.

However, as film critic Roger Ebert points out: 

"It is getting harder and harder for satire to stay ahead of reality."

So what keeps a satire relevant? I think when it jabs home a perennial problem.  

In politics and war, that problem is attrition.  It's one thing to lose a battle to the other side, but when your own rank and file lose faith? Double ouch.

In the scene below:
- Ames, the political aide, is about to leave for the airport, but stops to overhear a phone conversation.
- Notice that this betrayal is not simply a jab in the gut, but is used to show the hurdles that the protagonists have.
- The irony is that one expects betrayal from a foe, not a supposed supporter.

INT. SIDE OFFICE. NIGHT.

 ...AMES: I'll see you at National.

BREAN NODS, AND EXITS.

HOLD ON AMES.
HE HEARS SOMETHING, AND TURNS.

ANGLE
HIS POV.
A YOUNG STAFFER, IN THE CORNER, SPEAKING SOFTLY ON THE PHONE.

STAFFER (ON PHONE): Tell him, well, tell him we, I know we just signed it, but we're going to cancel it. (PAUSE) Because, because we're not going to be staying here the next four years. (PAUSE) Well, I can't tell you on the phone.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: This is what satire does best: poke fun at our humanness.

Wag the Dog (1997)(10/4/96 draft)
by David Mamet
Based on the book, "American Hero," by Larry Beinhart

Monday, December 14, 2020

TODAY'S NUGGET: The Untouchables (1987) - The Wily, Crafty Trickster Role

[Quick Summary: Elliott Ness hunts Capone, helped by a worn beat cop, Malone.]

What was it about this Mamet script that swayed Sean Connery to take the role (and a rare pay cut)?  I think it's because Malone is such a great trickster role.

Malone, an entirely fictional character, is both sage and "bad cop" to the upstanding "good cop" Ness. He understands what motivates human nature.

In the scene below:
- Ness has just caught George, Capone's accountant, red handed with a shipment and a coded ledger. 
- Ness wants the code but George refuses. 
- Watch how Malone uses all his skills to create a crucible situation that put mental pressure on George.

EXT./INT. CABIN - DAY

MALONE (continuing): You going to talk? (beat) You're gonna talk, pal. You're gonna beg to talk.

In frustration, Malone takes the ledger.

MALONE: Somebody's going to talk.

He walks O.S., out onto the porch. WE HEAR him talking.

MALONE (O.S.)(continuing): Hey you, on your feet. We need you to translate this book. And you are going to. I won't ask you again.

EXT. THE CABIN - DAY

Malone has picked up the dead body of the slain bootlegger and is holding him up by the chin, while holding a pistol to the other. Malone shoves the pistol in the dead man's mouth.

MALONE: What's the matter. Can't you talk with a gun in your mouth? One...two...three...

He fires, as he heaves the body toward the open door.

INT. THE CABIN - DAY

The GUNSHOT, and the body flying through the door. Beat. Malone comes in the door.

He takes a step toward George, who is seated on a chair. The chair falls over, George struggles to his feet.

GEORGE: Yes. Yes. Yes...I'll...yesyesyes I'm going to...

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I like that nothing about this scene above is unearned. 

The threat is imminent (body a few feet away), so it's realistic that George is scared and willing to spill. 

The Untouchables (1987)
by David Mamet

Monday, December 7, 2020

TODAY'S NUGGET: Atlantic City (1980) - What I Wished I'd Known About Formatting

[Quick Summary: Lou, a numbers runner who yearns for his neighbor Sally, becomes an inadvertent drug courier for her estranged husband who arrives unexpectedly.]

Q: How good is this script? 
A: Good.* Really good.**

Lead actor Burt Lancaster said of his role:

A part like that, especially at my age, happens every ten years, if you’re lucky.

Q: But the script is written in the format of a play!
A: Here's what I wished I'd known about formatting as a new writer (but you can't tell new writers until they figure it out for themselves): It's not about formatting.

Q: But I LIKE doing the formatting.  Don't you?
A: I love it. It gives me a sense of "control" over the story.

Q: What's wrong with that?
A: Nothing, unless I'm using it to hide from the truth. ex. I simply can't fix this story.  It's the formatting!  Or my characters are flat. It's the formatting!  

Q: So focus on ...what?
A: I think the writer's job is to get the reader to go in with the character, and wonder where he came from, where he's going.  

If the reader is focusing on commas and periods, you've failed.

In the scene below:
- Notice how writer (and playwright) John Guare keeps you wondering why this very neat older man is  living in a doomed building. Who is ringing for him?
- Also note that you're so into Lou's world that the format falls away.

INT. LOU'S APARTMENT. DAY.

LOU IS A MAN IN HIS 60'S, VERY FIT, VERY HEARTY. IT SEEMS
A SURPRISE TO SEE HIM IRON A TIE IN HIS ONE-ROOM APARTMENT
IN THIS DOOMED BUILDING.
BEHIND HIM A BELL RINGS. AND RINGS.
THE BELL IS CONNECTED IN A VERY MAKESHIFT MANNER TO A
CLOTHESLINE LEADING DOWNSTAIRS.
THE APARTMENT IS ALARMINGLY BARE, EVEN THOUGH HE HAS
LIVED HERE HOW MANY YEARS NOW---THIRTY? CALENDARS
ON THE WALLS. OLD MAGAZINES. THAT'S ABOUT IT.
LOU TAKES HIS TIME. HE BUTTONS HIS SHIRT VERY CAREFULLY.
HE IS A VERY NEAT GUY.
HE TAKES A PAIR OF CLEAN SOCKS FROM THE LAUNDRY PILE.
HE STUFFS THE SOCK INTO THE BELL. IT QUIETS IT, BUT IT
DOESN'T STOP ITS PULLING.
HE LOOKS OUT THE WINDOW.
LOU'S POV. WE SEE SALLY, DAVE AND CHRISSIE FROM ABOVE
ENTERING THE BUILDING.

WHAT I'VE LEARNED: If musicians reading music can't wait for the next sequence of notes, the last thing they're looking at is the staff paper.

Atlantic City (1980)
by John Guare

*I am terribly impressed that it was written for a $5M budget and on a time crunch (begun in Aug., 1979, & shot Oct. 1979-Jan. 1980).

**Also, it received five Oscars nominations for:
- John Guare (Best Writing)
- Burt Lancaster (Best Actor)
- Susan Sarandon (Best Actress)
- Louis Malle (Best Director)
- Best Picture

perPage: 10, numPages: 8, var firstText ='First'; var lastText ='Last'; var prevText ='« Previous'; var nextText ='Next »'; } expr:href='data:label.url' expr:href='data:label.url + "?&max-results=7"'