[Quick Summary: To avoid greedy wholesalers, one fishing family tries to go against the grain and buy their own boat.]
One thing that I admire about writer-director Luchino Visconti's scripts is his ability to keep the stakes high, even if the story seems smallish.
For example, today's script is a story about a group of fisherman who can't get ahead because the fish wholesalers hold the upper hand on prices.
The story seems small because it involves fish prices. However, everyone can identify with the unfairness when there's a discrepancy in bargaining power.
How do you keep the stakes going though? Today's scene below demonstrates the increase in stakes into a family's revolution:
- The Valastro family is made up of three generations of fishermen.
- Anotonio, one of the Valastro sons, leads one of the best teams of fishermen.
- Antonio started an argument on the job and was jailed recently.
- The fish wholesalers withdrew their complaint when they realized their total catches dropped significantly because Antonio wasn't there to work.
- Antonio is emboldened by the pressure (barely making a living, unfairness) and his youth (energy, willingness to suffer and mortgage the house). They have less to lose than the older folk, who have less time.
- Up until this point, this family has done what its told, i.e., the safe thing. By revolting, Antonio is putting the whole family at risk.
- Note how the writer kicks up the stakes to a new high by putting Antonio at a fork in the road between two bad choices: stay suppressed, or risk the well being of his whole family.
Valastro house. Dining room. Day.
Cola, Antonio, and the grandfather are seated at the table. Mara is sewing. The mother enters with the pot, which she places on the table. As Cola slices the bread, the mother fills the plates with soup. Vanni's song is heard in the distance. Antonio is about to start eating but then pushes his plate away.
...Antonio turns back to the table suddenly and speaks to the entire family.ANTONIO: Did you see? They put us in jail because the law says we committed a crime. But when it suits their purpose the law doesn't count any more. So they spring us! Can you understand what this means? I'll tell you!
Antonio takes a chair near the door through which Lucia now enters, stopping to listen. Antonio sits down at the table and continues to talk, growing increasingly excited.
ANTONIO: It means they need us!
COLA (bitterly): How can anyone need us? We're just draft animals, like Jano's donkey. Who could need us? The fish, to get themselves caught!
ANTONIO (excited): I tell you they need us! So why do we always have to be under them! Let's forget them! And see how they do then! Let's see how far they get without us!
GRANDFATHER: Antonio, whoever leaves the old road finds a worse road!
ANTONIO: Grandfather, your proverbs were good once upon a time but not any more! Don't think I've gone crazy. I think with my head, not my feet! I don't want to hurt anybody. (He hits the table.) But I tell you we weren't born to be beggars, to not even hope to better our lives...but to at least control our own lives and those of our families!
GRANDFATHER: Your father always worked and he never complained!
COLA: Yes, but our father drowned, past Cape Mulini. Who ever thanked him? After he slaved all his life for other people! Who ever thinks of him now, or of all the other men who've died at sea slaving for other people? (He hits the table and suddenly stands up and goes over to the window.) Antonio's right! I'm not sure why, but Antonio's right! (He leans against the wall and speaks to the whole family.) If we worked on our own, everything we did would be for our house, for our mother and our sisters. When our father was alive he understood these things. He'd have gone along with Antonio. He sure wouldn't have wanted his sons to keep on like this!
Antonio hits his hand against the table and stands up, shouting.
ANTONIO: You see, you understand too.
Vanni, off-screen, stops singing. Lucia comes to the table as Antonio walks toward the door.
ANTONIO: If we all agree, we'll be rid of these bloodsuckers forever!
COLA: What should we do, Antonio?
ANTONIO: I want to get free of these "dealer" crooks and free you all too! (He turns around to face the family as the mother silently carries the pot back to the kitchen.) We'll work on our own, with our own boat! (Vanni enters from the courtyard to listen and leans against the doorway.) And our women'll help salt the fish... (Cola comes over to his brother.) And we'll sell it and go right to Catania!
COLA: It'll take money to do that, and we haven't got any!
ANTONIO: Don't worry, Cola; we have the house!
Antonio puts his hand on Cola's shoulder and goes out into the courtyard with him. Lucia, the grandfather, and Vanni watch them go.
WHAT I'VE LEARNED: I'd forgotten the simple power of a protagonist facing two bad decisions that seriously affect those he holds the dearest. It's hard not to be emotionally engaged and want to see what happens next.
La Terra Trema (1948)
by Luchino Visconti